"The Reformed' church at Montague, N. J., which has recently been rebuilt, was dedicated to the worship of God on the 18th of July. Rev. J. L. Stillwell a former pastor, presided and delivered a brief address. Rev. T. H. MacKenzie preached an impressive sermon from I. Tim. iii. 15, after which the venerable S. W. Mills, D.D., led in the dedicatory prayer. The other ministers who took part in the exercises were Revs. Thomas Kichols, D.D., W. A Mackenzie, T. D. Harris and Charles H. Whittaker." - as reported on page 193 of the August 3rd, 1899 issue The Christian Work: illustrated family newspaper, Vol. 67.
The current building is the third structure for this congregation. The Minisink Dutch Reformed congregation dates to 1737.